Decisions

Stuck on a decision? How to break out of decision paralysis

Decision paralysis is when a choice feels so big that you keep researching, asking for opinions and postponing instead of deciding. To break it, name the real decision, set a deadline, cut the options to two, ask which one you’d regret not trying, and take one small step this week that tests your choice.

What is decision paralysis?

It’s the loop of thinking about a decision without ever making it. You build another spreadsheet, poll another friend, wait for a sign. Weeks go by, and the decision is still sitting there.

It isn’t a lack of smarts. Often it’s the opposite: you can see every angle, so every option looks risky. The ones I hear about most are career and life choices, like changing jobs, taking a promotion, starting a business, moving or ending a partnership.

“Decision paralysis” is an everyday phrase, not a diagnosis. More on that below.

Why smart people get stuck

There’s rarely one reason. Usually it’s a mix of these four.

  • Too many options. Every extra choice adds one more thing to compare and one more thing to lose.
  • Waiting for certainty. Big decisions rarely come with it, and waiting is a choice too.
  • Other people’s voices. It gets hard to separate what you want from what you think you should want.
  • Fear of the wrong call. Plenty of decisions can be undone, but we treat them all as if they can’t.

Do more options really hurt?

Sometimes. You may have heard of the famous jam study. In 2000, psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper set up a tasting table in an upscale grocery store with either 6 jams or 24. More shoppers stopped at the big display. But 30% of people who saw the small display bought a jar, compared with 3% of those who saw the big one.

That’s a striking result, and it’s often told as proof that more choice is always bad. The fuller picture is more interesting. In 2010, Benjamin Scheibehenne, Rainer Greifeneder and Peter Todd pooled 50 experiments with more than 5,000 participants in a meta-analysis in the Journal of Consumer Research. On average, the effect of having more options was virtually zero. But the results varied a lot from study to study. Sometimes more choice hurt, sometimes it helped, and they couldn’t pin down exactly when.

So I don’t tell people that options are the enemy. What I see is narrower: when you’re already stuck, keeping five options open is usually a way to avoid choosing. Cutting to two forces the real comparison.

How to get unstuck

  1. Name the real decision. Write it as one question with a yes or no answer. “Do I take the London role?” is a decision. “What should I do with my career?” is a fog.
  2. Set a deadline. Put a date on the calendar. Open-ended decisions tend to stay open.
  3. Cut it to two options. If you’re still weighing five, you’re researching, not deciding.
  4. Ask the regret question. A year from now, which would you regret more: trying it, or not trying it?
  5. Check whose voice it is. For each reason, ask whether it’s yours or someone else’s.
  6. Take one small step. A call, a conversation or a trial run that tests the choice this week.

Why the regret question works

Because it pulls you out of the next five minutes and into the long view.

In a 1995 review in Psychological Review, psychologists Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Medvec described a pattern in how people experience regret over time. In the short term, people regret things they did more. In the long run, they regret things they didn’t do more.

That doesn’t mean the bold choice is always right. It means the fear you feel today about acting may not be the regret you’ll actually carry later. Asking the question out loud helps you weigh both.

How much information is enough?

Less than you think. Waiting for certainty is one of the most common ways people stay stuck.

In his 2016 letter to Amazon shareholders, Jeff Bezos wrote that most decisions should probably be made with somewhere around 70% of the information you wish you had. If you wait for 90%, he wrote, you’re probably being slow. He added that being good at noticing and correcting bad decisions makes being wrong less costly than you might think.

That’s advice for running a company, not a study, and your decision may not be a business one. But the idea carries over. Before you gather more information, ask: what exactly am I waiting to learn? If you can’t name it, you may already know enough.

Can the decision be undone?

Ask what it would really take to reverse it. In the same letter, Bezos describes many decisions as “two-way doors”: reversible choices that can use a lighter process. For those, he asks, so what if you’re wrong?

Many job, project and business decisions can be adjusted later, at some cost. Treat those as experiments and move faster. Save the slow, careful process for the few that are truly hard to take back.

Why one small step matters

Because deciding and doing are different problems. Plenty of people make a decision and then never act on it.

One of the best-studied tools for closing that gap is called an implementation intention. It’s a simple if-then plan: “If it’s Tuesday at 9, then I’ll call the recruiter back.” In a 2006 meta-analysis, Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran looked at 94 independent tests involving 8,461 participants. Making if-then plans had a medium-to-large positive effect on reaching goals.

So don’t just pick a step. Pick when and where you’ll take it. Write it down. Then see what you learn.

When it’s really a conversation

A lot of stuck decisions are really about a conversation you’re avoiding: telling your boss you want a different role, telling a cofounder you want out, telling family about your plans.

If that’s you, the decision may already be made. Read how to have a difficult conversation at work. If it’s tangled up with a conflict at work, a workplace conflict consultation may be the better place to start.

How one session helps

An outside view breaks a loop faster than another week of thinking alone. In one session we name the real decision, sort what you want from what you think you should want, and pick one step to take that week.

I won’t decide for you. I’ll ask the questions you’ve been avoiding.

Consultation, not therapy. I offer brief, solution-focused consultations centered on one goal. It isn’t therapy, mental health treatment or crisis care. If being stuck comes with ongoing anxiety or low mood that affects daily life, a licensed mental health professional is the right place to start. In a crisis, call or text 988 or call 911.

Sources

  1. Scheibehenne, B., Greifeneder, R., & Todd, P. M. (2010). Can there ever be too many options? A meta-analytic review of choice overload. Journal of Consumer Research, 37(3), 409-425. Also the source for the Iyengar and Lepper (2000) jam study description. doi.org
  2. Gilovich, T., & Medvec, V. H. (1995). The experience of regret: What, when, and why. Psychological Review, 102(2), 379-395. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  3. Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69-119. doi.org
  4. Bezos, J. (2017). 2016 Letter to Shareholders. Amazon. aboutamazon.com
  5. National Institute of Mental Health. Anxiety Disorders. nimh.nih.gov
FAQ

Quick answers

Is decision paralysis a mental health condition?

It’s an everyday phrase for getting stuck on a choice, not a diagnosis. Feeling anxious about a big decision is a normal part of life. The National Institute of Mental Health notes that anxiety disorders involve more than occasional worry: the anxiety doesn’t go away, shows up in many situations and can get worse over time. If that sounds like you, please talk with a licensed mental health professional. A consultation focuses only on the decision right in front of you.

How long should a big decision take?

Long enough to gather the facts that matter, and no longer. Set a deadline that fits the stakes, and be clear about exactly what information you’re still waiting for.

Is having too many options the problem?

Sometimes, but not always. Research on choice overload is mixed. If you’re stuck, though, cutting to two options is a simple way to move from researching to deciding.

What if I make the wrong choice?

Many choices can be adjusted. Decide with what you know now, watch what happens and change course if you need to. A decision you can learn from beats months of standing still.

Should I just go with my gut?

Your gut is information, not a verdict. Notice what it’s telling you, then check it against the facts and the regret question. If they agree, you probably have your answer.

Can you just tell me what to do?

I’ll be direct about what I see, and I’ll push back when your reasons don’t add up. The decision itself stays yours, because you’re the one who has to live with it afterward.

What should I send before a session?

A paragraph or two about the decision, the options you’re weighing and what’s holding you back. Please leave out any health or medical information about yourself or others.

Get started

Ready to make the call?

A paragraph or two about what’s going on is plenty. I’ll get back to you to set up a time.