Why it feels so hard
Because something real is at stake: your job, your reputation, a working relationship you rely on every day. So we wait for the perfect moment, rehearse our arguments in the shower and hope it all fixes itself. It rarely does.
You’re far from alone in holding back. In a study published in the Journal of Management Studies, NYU Stern researchers Frances Milliken, Elizabeth Morrison and Patricia Hewlin interviewed 40 full-time employees. 34 of them (85%) said that at least once they had felt unable to raise a concern with their boss, even though they thought the issue was important.
Their reasons will sound familiar. The most common was fear of being labeled, as a “troublemaker” or a “complainer.” Next came fear of damaging a relationship, then the feeling that speaking up wouldn’t change anything, then fear of retaliation.
Those fears make sense. But the waiting is usually worse than the conversation would be, and the problem keeps growing while you wait.
It’s three conversations
One of the most useful ideas I know about hard talks comes from the Harvard Negotiation Project. In their book Difficult Conversations, Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton and Sheila Heen explain that every tough conversation is really three conversations at once:
- What happened. Who said what, who’s right and who’s to blame. Arguing about blame keeps you from finding out what actually happened.
- Feelings. Hurt, anger, embarrassment. Left alone, these tend to deepen the conflict.
- Identity. The one you have with yourself. Am I competent? Am I a good person? Conflict can shake both.
Knowing this helps you prepare. Most people only prepare for the first one, the facts. Then the other two show up uninvited. If you know you’ll feel defensive when your competence is questioned, you can plan for it.
What to prepare
Less than you think. You don’t need a script. You need three things:
- One outcome. What do you want to be different afterward? Keep it to one.
- The facts. Two or three specific examples, with dates if you have them.
- Your opening. The first two sentences, written down, so you don’t stall or ramble.
It also helps to answer two quiet questions before you go in. What might they be feeling about this? And what part of this touches your sense of who you are at work?
What to actually say
Open with the point, not a warm-up. Long wind-ups make the other person nervous and bury the message you came to deliver.
Try something like this:
- “I want to talk about how deadlines get set on our team. I’ve missed two because I found out late, and I’d like to fix that.”
- “I have some feedback on Tuesday’s meeting. Do you have fifteen minutes now, or is tomorrow better?”
- “We keep clashing in planning meetings, and I don’t think either of us likes it. Can we figure out what’s going on?”
Then stop talking. Silence is fine. Let them respond in their own time.
Describe, don’t diagnose
“You interrupted me twice in the client call” works. “You’re disrespectful” starts a fight.
There’s research behind this. In a large 1996 review in Psychological Bulletin, Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi analyzed 607 effect sizes from studies of feedback. On average, feedback improved performance. But in over a third of cases, it made performance worse. Their explanation: feedback works less well as attention moves away from the task and toward the self. Writing later in Harvard Business Review, Kluger and Guy Itzchakov put it this way: the drop happened mostly when the feedback threatened how people saw themselves.
So keep your words on the behavior and the work, where the other person can do something about it. Leave their character out of it. That isn’t about being soft. It’s about being heard.
The steps, start to finish
- Pick the time and place. Private, in person or on video. Not right before a deadline, and not by text.
- Say the point first. One plain sentence about the issue.
- Describe, don’t diagnose. Stick to what happened and its effect on the work.
- Ask for their side. “How do you see it?” Then listen without planning your comeback.
- Check what you heard. Say back the main point in your own words before you respond.
- Agree on one next step. Who does what, and by when.
- Follow up. A short note afterward with what you agreed keeps it from fading.
Steps 4 and 5 are where most hard conversations are won or lost. People rarely change their mind while they feel unheard. In the same HBR article, Itzchakov and Kluger note that feedback can backfire when people get defensive, and describe research exploring whether attentive, non-judgmental listening can help instead. Listening well doesn’t mean agreeing. It means the other person can tell you understood them.
Why not email or Slack?
Writing feels safer. You get to choose every word, and nobody can interrupt. But tone is the first thing to go.
In a 2005 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Justin Kruger, Nicholas Epley and colleagues asked people to get across emotions and tones, such as sarcasm or seriousness, either by email, by voice or face to face. Across five experiments, people overestimated how well their email would come across. In one experiment, people on the receiving end of an email thought they had read the tone right 89% of the time. They actually got it right 63% of the time, compared with about 74% face to face.
The authors trace this to something we all do. When you write, you “hear” your own tone in your head, and it’s hard to remember that the reader can’t.
So use writing to set up the talk and to confirm what you agreed afterward. Have the real conversation in person, by video or by phone.
What if it goes badly?
Some conversations get heated. If that happens, slow down and name it: “This is getting tense, and I want to get it right.” Then suggest picking it up later that day or tomorrow.
Naming the feeling isn’t just politeness. In a brain imaging study published in Psychological Science, UCLA researcher Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that putting feelings into words, which they call affect labeling, reduced the response of the amygdala and other emotion-related brain regions to negative images. That was a lab study, not a meeting room, so I don’t want to oversell it. But it fits what many of us notice: saying “I’m frustrated” out loud can take a little of the heat out of it.
A pause isn’t a failure. It gives you both time to cool down.
If what’s going on involves harassment, discrimination or safety, take it to HR or the right authority, not just a one-on-one conversation with the other person. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has information on harassment and how to report it.
When a consultation helps
When the conversation keeps getting postponed, or when you’ve had it three times and nothing has changed.
In one session we get clear on what you want, find the words and practice the opening out loud until it sounds like you. We also plan for the pushback you expect, and for the moment you’ll most want to get defensive.
If the talk is part of a bigger standoff at work, see my guide to workplace conflict consultations in NYC.
Consultation, not therapy. I offer brief, solution-focused consultations built around one goal. It isn’t therapy, mental health treatment or crisis care, and it isn’t a substitute for them. In a crisis, call or text 988, or call 911 for an emergency.
Sources
- Milliken, F. J., Morrison, E. W., & Hewlin, P. F. (2003). An exploratory study of employee silence: Issues that employees don’t communicate upward and why. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6). doi.org
- Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. What are Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most (on Stone, Patton & Heen, Difficult Conversations). pon.harvard.edu
- Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254-284. doi.org
- Itzchakov, G., & Kluger, A. N. (2018). The Power of Listening in Helping People Change. Harvard Business Review. hbr.org
- Kruger, J., Epley, N., Parker, J., & Ng, Z.-W. (2005). Egocentrism over e-mail: Can we communicate as well as we think? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89(6), 925-936. doi.org
- Lieberman, M. D., et al. (2007). Putting feelings into words: Affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421-428. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Harassment. eeoc.gov