Consultations for work conflict

Workplace conflict consultations in NYC

A workplace conflict consultation is short, practical help with one specific problem at work: the coworker you clash with, the boss you can’t read, or the team that stopped talking. With me, Dr. Niloo Dardashti (Dr. D), you start with one session in New York City or by video, find the real issue, and leave knowing your next conversation.

Conflict at work is normal

If you’re in a standoff at work, you’re not unusual. In a 2008 survey of 5,000 full-time employees in nine countries, CPP (the publisher of the Myers-Briggs assessment) found that 85% of employees deal with conflict to some degree. US employees in that survey reported spending 2.8 hours a week dealing with it.

The same survey points to the habit that makes it worse. Two thirds of employees (67%) said they had gone out of their way to avoid a colleague because of a disagreement, and in the US that figure was 76%. Avoiding the person feels safer in the moment. It rarely ends the conflict. It just moves it into hallways, side chats and silent meetings.

So the goal isn’t a workplace with no conflict. It’s getting better at the conflict you already have.

What is a conflict consultation?

It’s focused, one-on-one consultation about a conflict you’re in right now. Not a workshop, not a personality test, and not a referee who decides who’s right.

We look at three things:

  • What’s actually happening between you and the other person, separated from the story you’ve built about it.
  • What each of you wants, underneath what each of you keeps saying.
  • What keeps the standoff going, including the part you play.

Then we plan what you’ll say and do next.

I see the workplace as a second family. People bring the same habits to work that they bring everywhere else, which is why the same fight can come back with a different coworker. Seeing your part in the pattern is often the fastest way out of it.

Why it gets personal so fast

Researchers often split conflict at work into two kinds. Task conflict is about the work: priorities, deadlines, how to do something. Relationship conflict is about the people: tension, irritation, the feeling that someone doesn’t respect you.

For years, the popular advice was that task conflict is healthy and only relationship conflict hurts. A widely cited 2003 meta-analysis in the Journal of Applied Psychology tested that idea. Carsten De Dreu and Laurie Weingart pooled the research on teams and found that both kinds of conflict had a moderate, negative link with team performance and with team members’ satisfaction. They also found that disagreements about the work did less damage when they stayed separate from personal tension.

In plain words: a disagreement about the work turns costly when it becomes a disagreement about each other. The authors point to trust and openness on the team as what helps keep the two apart.

That’s a lot of what we do in a session. We pull the work problem back out of the personal one, so you can solve the part that can actually be solved.

Who is it for?

Professionals, managers, founders and executives, in NYC or by video. Some examples:

  • A coworker who undermines you, takes credit or shuts you out
  • A manager who micromanages, goes quiet or sends mixed signals
  • Cofounders who no longer agree on the big decisions
  • A team where people talk about each other instead of to each other
  • Feedback you need to give and keep putting off

Conflict with your boss

A lot of the conflicts people bring me are with a manager, and the research suggests that’s common. In the CPP survey, about a quarter of employees (24%) named conflict between line managers and their reports as the kind they saw most at work, second only to conflict between entry-level and front-line staff.

Conflict with a boss feels riskier because it is. They have a say in your work, your reviews and sometimes your next job. That doesn’t mean you stay quiet. It means you prepare more carefully.

In a session we work out what your manager cares about, what you need from them, and how to raise it as a problem to solve rather than a complaint. Usually that means leading with the effect on the work, bringing one specific example and offering one suggestion.

What happens in one session?

Before we meet, you send a paragraph or two about what’s going on. In the session, by video or phone, we get specific: what happened, what you’ve tried and what you want to be different.

I’m direct, so expect honest questions. Who said what? What did you want to happen? What would the other person say you’re doing? What have you been avoiding?

You leave with a clear next step, usually the first conversation to have and the words to open it. Want to keep going? Add a short run of sessions while you carry out the plan.

Does coaching actually help?

It’s a fair question, and the honest answer is that the research is promising but still young.

A 2014 meta-analysis in The Journal of Positive Psychology by Tim Theeboom, Bianca Beersma and Annelies van Vianen at the University of Amsterdam pooled 18 studies of coaching in organizations. They found positive effects on all five outcome groups they looked at: performance and skills, well-being, coping, attitudes toward work, and goal-directed self-regulation, which means setting goals and working toward them.

Two findings stand out for a brief approach like mine. In their exploratory analysis, the number of sessions wasn’t significantly related to how well coaching worked, and they noted that coaching can be effective even when the number of sessions is relatively small. They also noted that many of the shorter programs used solution-focused coaching, which moves straight to finding solutions instead of analyzing the problem at length.

The authors are careful about limits, and so am I. The studies were few, many relied on self-reports, and results varied a lot from study to study. Coaching isn’t a guarantee. What it can give you is a clear plan, practiced words and an outside view, which is often what’s missing when you’ve been stuck in a conflict for months.

What can you do this week?

Before you talk to anyone, try this:

  1. Name the real issue. Write one sentence about the behavior that bothers you, not their character.
  2. Separate facts from stories. List what happened. Cross out what you’re guessing about their motives.
  3. Find the interest under the position. Ask what you each actually need, not what you each keep demanding.
  4. Know what you want. Pick one change to ask for, small enough that they can say yes.
  5. Check your part. Ask yourself what they’d say you do that makes it worse. Be honest.
  6. Choose the setting. Talk privately, in person or on video, when neither of you is rushed.

Step 3 comes from negotiation research. The Harvard Negotiation Project’s book Getting to Yes, by Roger Fisher, William Ury and Bruce Patton, separates positions, the fixed demands people state, from interests, the needs and concerns underneath them. Harvard’s Program on Negotiation gives a simple example: two siblings argue over a restaurant or a party at home, until it turns out one has no time to prepare and the other is worried about cost. An affordable restaurant solves both.

Work conflicts often look the same. “I need to own this project” can mean “I’m worried about being overlooked for promotion.” Once you know that, there may be more than one way to give the other person what they need.

Then have the conversation. My guide on how to have a difficult conversation at work walks through what to say, step by step, and what to do if it gets heated.

When the team is the problem

Sometimes it isn’t one person. It’s a team where people have stopped raising problems out loud.

Harvard Business School professor Amy Edmondson calls the opposite of that psychological safety: “a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking.” In her 1999 study of work teams, published in Administrative Science Quarterly, psychological safety was linked to the learning behavior teams need, like asking for help, raising mistakes and seeking feedback.

The American Psychological Association’s 2024 Work in America survey of 2,027 US workers echoes this. Workers who reported lower psychological safety were far more likely to call their workplace toxic, 30% compared with 3% of those who reported higher psychological safety. Overall, 15% of workers described their workplace as somewhat or very toxic.

Along with one-on-one consultations, I work with teams and companies on conflict, difficult conversations and communication. Company work can be on-site in New York or by video. If this is for your team, choose “My team or company” on the contact form and describe the situation.

How is this different from HR or therapy?

HR works for the company and handles policy, complaints and investigations. A consultation is your space to think out loud, get a direct, honest outside view and plan your next move.

A consultation doesn’t replace reporting harassment, discrimination or safety concerns to HR or the right authority. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission encourages employees to report harassment to management early, before it escalates. It also notes there are deadlines for filing a charge with the EEOC, generally 180 days, which state laws may extend. If that’s your situation, start there.

Consultation, not therapy. I offer brief, solution-focused consultations built around one goal. It isn’t therapy, mental health treatment or crisis care, and it isn’t a substitute for them. In a crisis, call or text 988, or call 911 for an emergency.

Sources

  1. CPP, Inc. (2008). Workplace Conflict and How Businesses Can Harness It to Thrive (CPP Global Human Capital Report). jamspathways.com
  2. De Dreu, C. K. W., & Weingart, L. R. (2003). Task versus relationship conflict, team performance, and team member satisfaction: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(4), 741-749. doi.org
  3. Theeboom, T., Beersma, B., & van Vianen, A. E. M. (2014). Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 9(1), 1-18. doi.org
  4. Shonk, K. Principled Negotiation: Focus on Interests to Create Value. Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. pon.harvard.edu
  5. Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350-383. doi.org
  6. American Psychological Association (2024). 2024 Work in America Survey. apa.org
  7. US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Harassment. eeoc.gov
FAQ

Quick answers

Do you meet in person in NYC?

Sessions are by video or phone, so you can join from anywhere. I’m based in New York City, and company and team work can be on-site.

How many sessions will I need?

Many people start with one session and leave with a clear plan. If you want support while you carry it out, you can add a short run of sessions built around one goal.

What if the conflict is with my boss?

That’s one of the most common situations. We work out what your manager cares about, what you need from them, and how to raise it as a problem to solve rather than a complaint.

Can you help if I’m the manager?

Yes. Managers often get caught between two people who won’t talk to each other. We plan how to talk to each person on their own, set clear expectations for both and follow up without siding with either one.

Is some conflict at work healthy?

Disagreement about the work is part of doing good work. The research above suggests the trouble starts when it turns personal. A consultation helps you keep the disagreement about the work.

Should I just avoid the person?

It’s tempting, and most people have done it. Avoiding someone usually keeps the conflict going quietly. A short, planned conversation tends to cost less than months of working around each other.

Is this confidential?

What you share in a consultation stays between us. I’m not part of your company’s HR process, and I don’t report to your employer.

How do I get started?

Send a paragraph or two about what’s going on through the contact form, and I’ll get back to you to set up a time if I think I can help. Please leave out health or medical details.

Get started

Ready to sort out the conflict?

A paragraph or two about what’s going on is plenty. I’ll get back to you to set up a time.